CAT Grammar – Modifiers – Types and Errors

Saturday, May 9th, 2020

CAT Grammar Modifiers Types and Errors

We all have studied modifiers in our school days. But since it is an optional element in the English language, it is not treated as an important topic. Then why do you need to learn about it now? Well, CAT and other MBA entrance exams often feature questions based on Sentence correction and these questions often contain modifier-based errors. Apart from that, it will help you improve your grammar and aid in tackling the verbal ability section.

But, what exactly is a modifier? What if, you want to be more specific while describing something? Well, that’s the very purpose of modifiers. As the name suggests, modifiers modify the meaning of the sentence, by making it more specific and detailed. Basically, modifier adds to the meaning of another element, on which it is dependent. The grammar of the sentence won’t be affected if you remove modifiers from the sentence.

Interestingly, they can assume the role of any type of parts of speech: adjectives, adverbs, adjective clauses, adverb clauses, prepositional phrases, participle phrases, infinitive phrases, etc. Modifiers can be a word, phrase or clause that qualifies other words in a sentence. Before learning about the kinds of errors that feature in modifier-based questions in CAT, let’s explore the various types of modifiers that we may come across:

Generally, modifiers take the following main forms:

  1. Adjective modifiers
  2. Adverb modifiers

Starting with the adjective modifiers, why do you think we need adjective modifiers? As you already know, adjectives are describing words. It modifies and describes a noun or pronoun. An adjective can function as a modifier in form of a single word, a phrase or a clause. Let’s discuss some examples for better understanding.

  • The seminar on energy conservation was attended by several  (Here, ‘several’ is an adjective that modifies the noun ‘activists’.)
  • Have you read the novel by Jane Austen? (Here, the adjective phrase ‘by Jane Austen’ modifies the noun ‘novel’.)
  • The cupboards stuffed to the brim need to be organized. (Here, the adjective phrase ‘stuffed to the brim’ modifies the noun ‘cupboards’. This adjective phrase is basically a participle phrase which modifies nouns.)
  • The company needs to find a person who will help to restore consumer confidence. (Here, ‘who will help to restore consumer confidence’ is an adjective clause that modifies the noun ‘person’.)

In other words, adjective modifiers answer the following questions with respect to the nouns they modify: What kind?, Which one?, How many? and, How much?

Another important type of modifiers is adverb modifiers. As you would guess, adverbs modify verbs, adjectives, and other adverbs. Similar to adjective modifiers, adverb modifiers feature in form of a single word, phrase or a clause. Let’s explore the various kinds of adverb modifiers with the help of examples.

  • She voluntarily offered help to an old woman to cross the road. (Here, the adverb ‘voluntarily’ modifies the verb ‘offered’.)
  • Selena would be extremely grateful if you could have a word with Jack. (Here, the adverb ‘extremely’ modifies the adjective ‘grateful’.)
  • John fell and hurt his leg rather (Here, the adverb ‘rather’ modifies another adverb ‘badly’.)
  • Sia was surprised to see all her friends seated in the front row. (The adverb phrase ‘in the front row’ modifies the verb ‘seated’. An adverb phrase is basically a prepositional phrase which modifies verbs, adjectives and adverbs.)
  • When Jack was about eight years old, his father died. (Here, ‘When Jack was about eight years old’ is an adverb clause that modifies the verb ‘died’.)

By now, you must have observed that the adverb modifiers function as an answer to the following questions with respect to the nouns/verbs they modify: When?, Where?, How often? and, How much?

Apart from the main types of modifiers (adjectives and adverbs), you also know about the prepositional and participle phrases that function as modifiers. Let’s see some more points related to them:

  • Prepositional phrases begin with a preposition and end with a noun. These can function either as an adjective or as an adverb to modify nouns, verbs, etc. Additionally, they answer the following questions with respect to nouns/verbs they modify: Where?, When?, Who? and What?.
  • On the other hand, Participle phrases function as adjective modifiers to modify nouns. These begin with a past or present participle.

Further, modifiers are of two types according to their position with respect to the words they modify. These are pre-modifiers and post-modifiers. Most of the adjectives are pre-modifiers as they are generally placed before the nouns they modify. In contrast, most of the adverbs and prepositional phrases are post-modifiers since they come after the verbs/nouns they modify.

By now, you are well familiarized with the different kinds of modifiers. You must have observed that the modifiers make our sentences more effective and efficient. The next step is to learn about the kinds of errors that occur due to misplacement or incorrect usage of modifiers. Such errors change the meaning of the whole sentence. Generally, there are three major kinds of modifier errors:

  1. Misplaced Modifier
  2. Squinting Modifier
  3. Dangling Modifier

Let’s discuss each of these with examples.

As the name suggests, the misplaced modifiers seem to modify/ describe the wrong set of words due to their incorrect placement in the sentence. Example: Mathew wants to buy a car from a sales associate with winter tyres.

In the above example, which words are described by the modifier ‘with winter tyres’? Sure, it would seem that the ‘sales associate needs to have winter tyres’. Well, that itself conveys that there is something wrong in the sentence. Now, what do you think will be the correct sentence?

Correct sentence: Mathew wants to buy a car with winter tires from a sales associate.

As you would guess, this sentence definitely conveys the right meaning: ‘with winter tyres’ modifies the noun ‘car’.

Another type of modifier error is the squinting modifier. Sounds complex? Well, that’s also how it is to identify this kind of error. Basically, this error is caused due to improper placement of adverbs in the sentence. In such a case, the structure of the sentence may seem correct but the meaning becomes ambiguous. Example: Students who skip their lectures often score poor marks.

What do you think the sentence wants to convey? You must be wondering over these two meanings:

  • Students who frequently skip their lectures score poor marks.
  • Students who skip their lectures will score poor marks frequently.

But, why does this confusion exists? Well, because you can’t tell which part of the sentence the adverb ‘often’ modifies. For either of the meaning to exist, the correct form of sentences should be:

  • Students who often skip their lectures score poor marks.
  • Students who skip their lectures score poor marks

As you can see, there is no ambiguity in the meaning of either of the sentences. For the obvious reason, squinting modifier is also called two-way modifier.

The third type of modifier error is the dangling modifier. As the name suggests, a dangling modifier appears in sentences that seem incomplete. Such modifiers are placed in the beginning of the sentence which seems to miss the part being modified. Generally, these modifiers exist as participial phrases, prepositional phrases, or infinitive phrases. Example: At the age of seven, my family went on a trip to Victoria Falls.

What do you think the phrase ‘at the age of seven’ modifies? Well, you must have guessed that something is missing in the sentence. The correct way should be:

When I was seven, my family went on a trip to Victoria Falls.

Here, the phrase is changed to a dependent clause ‘When I was seven’.

Let’s take another example to get a better understanding of dangling modifiers.

Example: To win the game, a great effort was made. (What do the phrase ‘to win the game’ modifies?)

As you can guess, the subject is missing in this sentence. The correct way would be:

To win the task, she made a great effort.

Now that you know the kind of modifier errors, let’s explore some tips and rules to correct the modifier errors:

  • Try to place the modifier as close as possible to the word it modifies. This especially applies to adjective and adverb phrases, and clauses that start with who, whose, that, and which. Adverbs like only, just, nearly, almost often feature in error correction questions. Makes sure that they precede the words they modify.
  • In case of dangling modifiers, there would be no word for the modifier to modify. In such sentences, add a noun/pronoun right after the opening modifier or insert the noun being modified to the opening modifier itself.
  • If a modifier appears to qualify the words before and after it, change its position in the sentence. This is often the case with a squinting modifier.
  • Prefer to use an active voice in sentence correction.
  • Finally, avoid using too many modifiers as it results in confusion regarding the meaning of the sentence.

Now, you are well-versed with the different types of modifiers as well as modifier errors. The last step is to implement the above-stated rules and invest a good amount of time in practicing error-correction questions.

How to approach a case study based Group Discussion

You can also see: Group Discussion Tips – How to approach a topical Group Discussion

Written Ability Test – Evaluation Criteria and Recommended Background Reading

Essay Tips – Seven Deadly Sins of Essay Writing

How Many Essays You Must Write Before You Write an Essay

Online Coaching Course for CAT 2021 + Test Series

a) 1000+ Videos covering entire CAT syllabus
b) 2 Live Classes (online) every week for doubt clarification
c) Study Material & PDFs for practice and understanding
d) 10 Mock Tests in the latest pattern
e) Previous Year Questions solved on video

If you Like this post then share it!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.